Chapter 41&42 of Fantasyland

 Fantasy Land Ch. 41 & 42 

Madelyn Thurston 

Intro to Philosophy: Section 11 

 

Science  

In today's society, there exists a controversial fantasy with both topics. One involving the depths of knowledge and facts, and the other, with power and protection. Kurt Andersen, the author of Fantasy Land, and many others, talks about his experiences with vaccines during major pandemics, and the stigmatism around science recently. He also goes into a discussion on the fantasies people have about gun rights and shares some personal experiences. Within the past few years, we have seen both subjects circling, whether that be in media or just in everyday conversation.  

Are GMO’s bad for you? Scientists, multiple scientists, have done extensive research to disprove this claim, but there is still a huge stigmatism around the subject. Andersen, in the book Fantasy Land, exclaims, “of the scientists in the American Association for the Advancement of Science, 88 percent think it's safe to eat GMO foods. This is almost exactly the same percentage of those scientists who say climate change is real and man-made.” It is silly to back the science of professionals on one topic, but not another. In chapter 41, Andersen not only discusses GMOs, but it leads him to the arguments of vaccines. He mentions how he grew up during the polio outbreak and the flu epidemic, and how it took the lives of many people. In the early 1950’s, the first successful vaccine was created by US physician Jonas Salk. By 1957, cases had dropped by 52,400 and were down to just below 200 in 1961. But of course, people had their concerns. Rumors of it causing autism, Alzheimer's, or diabetes went around. Anderson mentions one doctor who studied 10 children that already showed signs of autistic behaviors before being vaccinated for certain things, and he took that and ran with it. None of his studies could be replicated, and countless other studies continued to prove his wrong. That is a huge ethical problem. A demand for certain preservatives to be taken out of drugs came about. It happened, and surprisingly enough... nothing changed. Autism diagnoses were still on the rise. The question was raised, “should vaccines continue to be required in schools?” What do you think?  

Guns 

In the past 11 months alone, more than 500 shootings have occurred in the U.S. At least one of them happening in Nashville, remarkably close to home. And for those of you who are not aware, after the shooting took children's lives, Colorado Representative, Lauren Boebert promoted a tee-shirt that read "Since we’re redefining everything, this is a cordless hole puncher.” To make fun of those who identify themselves differently, because of who the shooter was. Andersen, in chapter 42 of Fantasy Land, mentions the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School that happened in 2012, where 20 first graders were murdered. The shooter obtained his weapons from his mom’s legally purchased stockpile that she had because she had a “survivalist philosophy.” One of those guns included a rifle, which he killed her with. And he used a semi-automatic to murder the teachers and children. But even after, people continued to fantasize and try to blame alternative realities. Andersen mentions Alex Jones, who said that it was all fake and that the parents were faking their grieving on TV. The father of one of the kids tried to debunk the theories, and a pro-gun fantasists threatened to kill the guy.   

 Why do people let their fantasies get in the way of their moral senses? According to Andersen, “The experts say that most mass shooting killers are not psychotics or paranoid schizophrenics in the throes of clinical delusion: rather, they're citizens of Fantasyland, unhappy people with flaws and failures they blame on others, the system, the elitists, the world.”  Even though one the main desire for guns is self-defense, the chances of needing one in a situation like that are very unlikely. About 1 in 6 thousand Americans either display a gun or fires one in a form of self-defense during a robbery or assault. And only one person in the 6 million interviewed in 10 years used a gun in self-defense against sexual assault. So why are they being so heavily defended? When the founders wrote the constitution, they envisioned a very small permanent national military. If Americans needed to fight wars, the states would assemble their militias. When the constitution was written, the supreme court would not produce what the 2nd amendment really meant because all of the amendments were meant to change with time according to circumstances.  So as time went on it kept changing. In the 1970’s, a new political movement was born opposed to any firearms regulation. But there were 2 requirements. You had to pass an FBI background check, and certain semiautomatic guns and the mags that held more than 10 rounds were banned. The NRA kind of threw a fit about this and wrote a letter to fundraise and it was signed by Wayne LaPierre. In protest of this letter, President George H. W. Bush resigned from the NRA. Then, the anti-gun-regulation activist, Timothy McVeigh, blew up the Oklahoma City federal building. LaPierre and the gun right advocates did not stop there. They strived for the Supreme Court to ratify their new movement. In the 1990s, Chief Justice Warren Burger, a conservative appointed by Nixon, complained after he retired that the 2nd amendment “has been the subject of one of the greatest pieces of fraud- I repeat the word fraud- on the American public by special interest groups that I have ever seen in my lifetime.”  In cases in 2008 and 2010, the Supreme Court finally agreed to decide the fundamental meaning of the Second Amendment. In both cases, five justices went with the new reading. Now our constitution does indeed guarantee each one of us the right to own firearms. LaPierre says that FBI background checks “are just the first step in their long march to destroying our Second Amendment- protected rights.”  The NRA made sure that current federal law requires that the record of every gun buyer who goes through a background check be destroyed. Gregory Orr, a poet who inspired Andersen, wrote after he accidently killed his brother while hunting, “To hunt... To fire a gun is to have your imagination tangled up with fantasies of power.”